Eliminating Nuclear Threats

A Practical Agenda for Global Policymakers

 

REPORT OF THE INTERNATIONAL COMMISSION ON NUCLEAR NON-PROLIFERATION AND DISARMAMENT

GARETH EVANS and YORIKO KAWAGUCHI CO-CHAIRS                    Commission Members


TABLE OF CONTENTS

Contents

Co-chairs’ Preface

Synopsis: A Comprehensive Action Agenda

Abbreviations

PART I: SEIZING THE MOMENT

1. Why This Report, and Why Now

The Problem: A Global Threat Defying Complacency

The Opportunity: Renewing the Momentum for Action

This Commission’s Role: A Comprehensive Action Agenda

PART II: ASSESSING NUCLEAR THREATS AND RISKS

2. The Risks from Existing Nuclear-Armed States

The Destructive Capabilities of Existing Weapons

Numbers and Classes of Existing Weapons

Missiles and Missile Defence

Alert Status of Existing Weapons

System Vulnerabilities

Attitudes to Using Nuclear Weapons and Disarmament

3. The Risks from New Nuclear-Armed States

Why Non-Proliferation Matters

The Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty Under Strain

Risks of a Proliferation Surge

4. The Threat of Nuclear Terrorism

Possible State and Non-State Actors

Availability of Weapons and Material

Assessing the Risk of Nuclear Terrorist Attack

5. The Risks Associated with Peaceful Uses of Nuclear Energy

Likely Scale of the Civil Nuclear Energy Renaissance

Assessing the Proliferation Risks of Nuclear Energy Expansion

PART III: FORMULATING POLICY RESPONSES

6. Disarmament: Making Zero Thinkable

Delegitimizing Nuclear Weapons

Rethinking Deterrence

Rethinking Other Justifications for Retaining Nuclear Weapons

7. Disarmament: A Two-Phase Strategy for Getting to Zero

Why a Two-Phase Approach is Necessary

The Minimization Phase

The Elimination Phase

8. Non-Proliferation: Constraining Demand and Supply

Limiting the Demand for Nuclear Weapons

Limiting the Supply of Weapons, Materials and Technology

9. Strengthening the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty

Improving Safeguards and Verification

Improving Compliance and Enforcement

Strengthening the International Atomic Energy Agency

10. Strengthening Non-Proliferation Disciplines Outside the NPT

Non-NPT Treaties and Mechanisms

Applying Equivalent Obligations to States now Outside the NPT

11. Banning Nuclear Testing

Importance of the Comprehensive Nuclear-Test-Ban Treaty

Addressing Verification and Stockpile Reliability Concerns

12. Limiting the Availability of Fissile Material

The Proposed Fissile Material Cut-off Treaty

Pre-Existing Stocks

Fissile Material in Civil Programs

13. Sustaining an Effective Counter-Terrorism Strategy

Counter-Terrorism Strategy Generally

Securing Loose Weapons and Material

“Dirty Bombs”: Improved Control of Radioactive Material

Nuclear Forensics

14. Responsible Nuclear Energy Management

Sharing the Benefits of Nuclear Energy

The Three Ss: Managing Safeguards, Security and Safety

Prospects for Proliferation-Resistant Technology

Industry as a Non-Proliferation Partner

15. Multilateralizing the Nuclear Fuel Cycle

The Argument for Multilateralization

Assurance of Supply Proposals

Fuel Bank Proposals

Multilateral Facility Proposals

The Way Forward

PART IV: FROM POLICY TO ACTION: A COMPREHENSIVE AGENDA

16. A Package for the 2010 NPT Review Conference

The Importance of the Review Conference

Updating the “Thirteen Practical Steps” on Disarmament

Specific Measures to Strengthen the NPT and IAEA

The Middle East and Nuclear Weapon Free Zones

17. Short Term Action Agenda: To 2012 – Achieving Initial Benchmarks

Defining Short Term Objectives

Reducing Weapon Numbers: U.S. and Russian Leadership

Multilateral Disarmament: Preparing the Ground

Nuclear Doctrine: Beginning to Limit the Role of Nuclear Weapons

Force Postures: Movement on De-alerting and Deployment

North Korea and Iran

18. Medium Term Action Agenda: To 2025 – Getting to the Minimization Point

Defining Medium Term Objectives

Reducing Weapon Numbers

Parallel Security Issues: Missiles, Space, Biological and Conventional Weapons

Nuclear Doctrine and Force Postures: Consolidating Change

Other Elements in the Non-Proliferation and Disarmament Agenda 200

19. Longer Term Action Agenda: Beyond 2025 – Getting to Zero

Defining “Zero”: The Nature of the Task

General Conditions for Moving from Minimization to Elimination

Overcoming Specific Concerns of Particular States

20. Mobilizing and Sustaining Political Will

The Elements of Political Will: Leadership, Knowledge, Strategy and Process

Identifying the Key Actors

Focusing the Campaign: A Nuclear Weapons Convention?

Sustaining the Momentum: An Ongoing Monitoring Mechanism

Notes and Sources

Annex A: Commission Recommendations

Annex B: Members of the Commission

Annex C: How the Commission Worked

Index

Boxes

2-1 Impact of Strategic Nuclear Bombs on London and Mumbai

2-2 Nuclear Arsenals 2009

3-1 Key Elements of the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty

4-1 Basic Nuclear Weapon Designs: "Gun" and "Implosion"

4-2 Impact of Terrorist Nuclear Explosions in London and Mumbai

5-1 Reactors Planned, Proposed and Under Construction 2009

5-2 The Nuclear Fuel Cycle: Basic Terminology Non-Specialists Need to Know

7-1 The Comprehensive Action Agenda: Timelines

10-1 Major Non-Proliferation Measures Complementing the NPT

13-1 Priority Issues for the 2010 Nuclear Security Summit

16-1 “A New International Consensus on Action for Nuclear Disarmament”

16-2 Nuclear Weapon Free Zones

17-1 The Short Term Action Agenda – To 2012

18-1 The Medium Term Action Agenda – To 2025

19-1 The Longer Term Action Agenda – Beyond 2025

Next: Co-chairs’ Preface